Saturday, 31 October 2026

Planner's Take, 31 October 2026

This is an editorial article from BPS Planning, issued for discussion only.

There is a particular kind of planning document that nobody outside the profession ever reads and almost everybody inside it has written: the environmental impact assessment screening report. It runs to dozens of pages, costs real money, and in the overwhelming majority of ordinary housing schemes it concludes, after a careful march through soils, water, biodiversity, traffic and cultural heritage, that a full assessment is not required. The Department of Housing has now published draft regulations under which housing schemes of up to 250 homes would no longer need formal screening at all, and it is worth asking, calmly and without slogans, what is actually being given up and what is being gained.

What officials have taken to calling a traffic light system would work like this. Up to 250 units is green, and no formal screening is needed; between 250 and 750 is amber, and the scheme is screened; above 750 is red, and a full assessment is mandatory. Easy to miss is that the point at which assessment becomes compulsory, 500 homes for more than twenty years, would rise by half. Similar exclusion thresholds are proposed for overhead electricity lines, private roads and wastewater treatment plants below 10,000 population equivalent, which should help Uisce Éireann with the unglamorous upgrades so many towns are waiting on. None of it applies until Part 4 of the Planning and Development Act 2024 is commenced, which awaits the end of the council work-to-rule.

What most of the coverage has skated past is that green does not mean unexamined. Section 225 of the 2024 Act requires the council, for any scheme below an exclusion threshold, to examine its nature and location and to move to screening if the possibility of significant effects cannot be excluded. What disappears is the obligation on the developer to commission and submit the formal screening material, not the obligation on the State to look.

The Government's case is that this removes duplication. Minister of State John Cummins argues that environmental screening already happens when land is zoned, and that the lack of exclusion thresholds meant everything was being screened. The second claim is fair in practice, if not quite in law: the 2001 Regulations already required only a preliminary examination below the 500-unit line, but many applicants, knowing where judicial reviews are won and lost, have long submitted full screening reports as a matter of course. A study published with the Department's consultation found that fewer than one per cent of schemes below 250 homes ended up with a full assessment. Engineers Ireland, the Chartered Institute of Building and Cork Chamber all supported exclusion thresholds in the consultation, though the engineers wanted sensitive locations and cumulative effects still covered and the builders' institute wanted councils resourced to do the work. Sean O'Driscoll of the Accelerating Infrastructure Taskforce has compared Ireland's 2022 tally with 217 in Germany and eight in Denmark, though the Irish figure has been reported as both 257 assessments and 237 screenings, which is not a small difference in a debate about precision.

The objections deserve the same seriousness. Eoin Ó Broin of Sinn Féin spoke of a sense of déjà vu about light-touch regulation, and the Green Party's Malcolm Noonan has warned that flood plains, hedgerows and archaeology could be overlooked. Here the law is not on anyone's side so much as on its own. Zoning-stage assessment under the SEA Directive is expressly without prejudice to project assessment, and the European Court of Justice has held, against Ireland itself over peat extraction and land reclamation, that a threshold based on size alone, blind to nature and location, exceeds what the Directive permits. More recently it found Vienna's urban development thresholds set so high that most projects were excluded in advance. The new examination is what keeps the Irish system on the right side of that line, which is why it cannot be allowed to become a formality. Appropriate assessment under the Habitats Directive, the regime behind so many recent challenges, is untouched, and every scheme must still be screened for it.

My view is that the change is sensible in principle, and that its legality and its value rest on one thing: a nature and location examination done properly, by councils with the ecologists and resources to do it. If that happens, few outside the consultancies will mourn the routine screening report. If it does not, the time saved at the front of the process will be lost again at the back, in the courts, where Irish housing has already spent too much of the last decade.

Irish Town Planner Planning News Roundup, 31 October 2026

Here is today's round-up of town planning news from around Ireland, covering draft rules to exempt housing schemes of up to 250 homes from environmental screening, confirmation that the levy and water connection waiver ends this year, a refusal on density grounds at St Ann's Hill in Cork, 30 homes refused in Longford over wastewater capacity, an appeal over apartments in Castlebar and the delayed rural housing planning statement.

Draft rules would exempt schemes of up to 250 homes from EIA screening

The Department of Housing has published draft regulations under which housing developments of up to 250 units would no longer need environmental impact assessment screening, schemes of 250 to 750 units would be screened and a full assessment would be required above 750 units. Exclusion thresholds are also proposed for overhead electricity lines, private roads and wastewater treatment plants serving fewer than 10,000 population equivalent. The changes will take effect with the commencement of Part 4 of the Planning and Development Act 2024, which is not expected until the work-to-rule by council staff ends.

Source: RTÉ News (30 October 2026)

Minister rules out extending development levy and water connection waiver

Minister for Housing James Browne has said the waiver on development levies and Uisce Éireann connection charges, introduced in 2024, will not be extended beyond the end of December, so only homes finished by the end of 2026 will benefit. His comments followed Central Statistics Office figures showing 26,833 homes completed between January and September, compared with 24,256 in the same period last year. Opposition parties point out that the Government's suggested figure of about 40,000 homes this year remains well short of the 50,000 a year backed by the Housing Commission.

Source: RTÉ News (30 October 2026)

80 homes at former Hydro site in Tower refused over low density

An Coimisiún Pleanála has refused permission to OMD(C) Ltd for 55 houses and 25 apartments on the 11-hectare site of the former St Ann's Hydropathic Establishment at St Ann's Hill, Tower, Co Cork, overturning Cork City Council's June grant and its own inspector's recommendation. The scheme's density of 17.3 dwellings per hectare compared with a development plan minimum of 35 per hectare, and the Commission found the site's archaeological and heritage constraints did not justify such a departure. It concluded the scheme would be an inefficient and unsustainable use of zoned, serviced land.

Source: Irish Examiner (30 October 2026)

30 homes refused at Stonepark, Longford, over wastewater concerns

Longford County Council has refused permission for 30 homes, 24 three-bedroom and six two-bedroom houses, near the Silver Birches estate at Stonepark, Longford. Uisce Éireann and seven other parties made submissions, and local residents raised concerns that the existing sewage treatment plant serving the estate was already at capacity, along with water pressure, surface water and traffic issues. The decision was made on 20 October after further information was received in September.

Source: Longford Live (28 October 2026)

Castlebar Coal Bunker apartments refusal appealed

Developer Harold Conway has appealed Mayo County Council's refusal of permission for 12 apartments at the former Coal Bunker site at the junction of the Pontoon and Turlough roads in Castlebar, opposite the Sacred Heart Hospital. It is the council's second refusal on the site, following an earlier proposal for 19 units, and it found that residential use would materially contravene the site's Enterprise and Employment zoning in the Castlebar Town and Environs Local Area Plan. A decision on the appeal is due before the end of February.

Source: Connaught Telegraph (30 October 2026)

No date yet for new rural housing planning rules

The Department of Housing has confirmed that the draft Sustainable Rural and Gaeltacht Housing National Planning Statement, whose policy direction the Government agreed on 30 June, is still undergoing environmental assessment and has yet to go to public consultation. The statement is expected to address issues such as ribbon and backland development and local-needs criteria, and councils will have to review their development plans where they are significantly inconsistent with it. No date has been given for consultation, final Government approval or implementation.

Source: Selfbuild (30 October 2026)

Friday, 30 October 2026

Irish Planning History: Saving Dublin

There is a particular kind of Irish book that is written in a rage and read as a relief, and Frank McDonald's The Destruction of Dublin, which we looked at here last week, was one of them. McDonald himself, looking back in a 2008 Irish Times essay on the 1980s, confessed as much, admitting that he simply could not understand why the city was being treated by developers as a quarry and by road engineers as an inconvenience to traffic. But rage, however well documented, is not a policy, and the more interesting question for anyone who works in planning now is what came after the anger: how a city that one former Lord Mayor, the late Jim Mitchell, had likened to a knacker's yard managed, within a generation, to persuade people that it was a place worth living in again.

McDonald's own answer came four years after the first book, in Saving the City: How to Halt the Destruction of Dublin, published by Tomar in 1989 with, of all things, an introduction by Bob Geldof. The title is worth pausing on, because it marks a shift in register from lament to prescription, from the charge sheet to the to-do list, and that shift was happening not only in one journalist's head but across a whole loose coalition of citizens, students, clerics, senators and, eventually, ministers.

This piece was always going to lean heavily on McDonald, and it is hard to write it without noting that he is no longer here to quarrel with it. He died in September, after a short illness, at the age of 76, and The Irish Times, reporting his death, recalled that he had become the paper's first environment correspondent in 1986 on the back of his investigations into planning failures and dereliction in Dublin. It was a sad day for the city, and for anyone who cares about what becomes of it, whichever side of a planning appeal they happen to sit on.

A weekend in the Synod Hall

If the change of mood has a date, it is the weekend of 7 to 9 February 1986, when the Dublin Crisis Conference filled the old Synod Hall at Christchurch Place. McDonald, writing about it thirty years later, named the organisers as Dean Victor Griffin, Senator David Norris, Larry Dillon, Deirdre Kelly, Mick Rafferty, Donal Storey and himself, a list that tells you something in itself, running as it does from the Dean of St Patrick's to a north inner city community activist. They even got the Taoiseach, Garret FitzGerald, to turn up and respond to their conclusions, the principal one being a demand that the Government and the Dublin local authorities "recognise and accept that the city is in crisis".

It is easy, at this distance, to smile at a demand that amounts to asking officialdom to admit there is a problem, but anyone who has sat through a few council meetings will know that this is usually the hardest step of all. The conference asked for more than an admission, though. It called for the destructive road plans for the inner city to be abandoned, and for tax incentives to encourage people to live in the centre rather than merely to work in it. The papers, the conference report and a later Manifesto for the City survive in the Frank McDonald collection at Dublin City University, alongside a programme cover by Martyn Turner, which is about as Dublin as an archive gets.

The people problem

The real insight of the period, and the one that has aged best, was that buildings were never going to be saved by preservation orders alone. They would be saved, if at all, by people living in them. McDonald credited the late Deirdre Kelly, founder of the Living City Group, with driving this point home, and in his 2015 farewell piece he recalled that in 1986 regional planners saw no hope that the inner city could take even an extra 10,000 people. The idea Kelly pressed was not entirely home-grown. As McDonald noted in a 2018 Irish Times piece on the Leeson Street residents, drawing on the historian Erika Hanna, Kelly had been influenced by Jane Jacobs, whose The Death and Life of Great American Cities had argued in 1961 that city streets live by their mix of uses and the people on them, and who had helped to defeat Robert Moses's plan to drive a road through Washington Square in New York. Catriona Crowe, writing in The Dublin Review after Jacobs died in 2006, recalled first reading the book in the early 1980s in Mountjoy Square, just after one of the last clearances of Georgian tenements on Summerhill and Gardiner Street, which suggests the argument needed very little translation.

The numbers explain their pessimism. On McDonald's figures, the population of the inner city, the oval between the two canals, had fallen from about 250,000 in the mid-1920s to just 75,000 by 1991, so that only one Dubliner in twelve still lived in the historic core. Some of that decline was the welcome result of clearing the tenements and rehousing families in Marino, Crumlin and beyond, and it would be unfair to the public health reformers of the 1930s to pretend otherwise. But by the 1980s the drift had gone well past slum clearance into something closer to abandonment, with the centre treated as an office district ringed by ghettos, to borrow McDonald's own blunt phrase.

Tax, Temple Bar and the accidental village

The State's response was, characteristically, fiscal. Within months of the Synod Hall weekend the Government announced a tax incentive scheme for derelict areas, which, with the Urban Renewal Act 1986, brought the Custom House Docks and stretches of the quays into play. Planners have argued ever since about whether the property-based tax schemes that followed were a masterstroke or a mistake, and the honest answer is probably both: they got cranes moving where nothing else had, and they also produced a fair amount of the shoebox apartment, laid out along artificially lit corridors, that McDonald himself came to regret.

Temple Bar is the most instructive case, partly because it was saved by accident before it was saved by design. CIÉ had spent years from the 1970s quietly buying property between Dame Street and the Liffey for a central bus station, and, as Dublin City Council's archive notes, it let those buildings out cheaply in the meantime, which drew in artists, musicians and small traders who then became the most effective opponents of the bus station. Charles Haughey, never a man to leave a cultural flagship unclaimed, declared in 1987 that he wouldn't let CIÉ near the place. By February 1991 he was telling the Dáil that a new company, Temple Bar Properties, would acquire the CIÉ and Corporation holdings as a flagship project for Dublin's year as European City of Culture, and the Temple Bar Area Renewal and Development Act followed that summer.

What happened next is a lesson every regeneration agency should keep pinned above its desk. The cultural quarter that was meant to rival Covent Garden became, in McDonald's own words, "the temple of bars". None of that cancels out the new squares, the restored streets or the cultural buildings, but it does show how hard it is to plan for the bohemian life that had grown up there precisely because nobody was planning anything at all.

From protest to practice

The 1990s brought a quieter but in some ways more durable kind of saving. Dublin Civic Trust was founded in 1992 to show, by buying and repairing buildings, that old houses could be lived in and made to pay their way. Dublin Corporation, for its part, began to lead by example, and a Trinity College Dublin study of urban conservation in Dublin points to the Corporation's "Living Over the Shop" pilot at Nos. 2 and 3 Capel Street, two eighteenth-century buildings it owned, as the moment the local authority began to take a leadership role in conservation. The same study is a useful corrective to any rosy account of the decade, recording that conservationists were still going to court, and to Europe, over schemes they believed were wrong, and that some felt cooperation alone would never have been enough.

The legal turning point came with the Local Government (Planning and Development) Act 1999, which, as McDonald noted, meant Ireland belatedly adopted preservation laws comparable to the rest of Europe, though without the generous funding that usually goes with them. In the same year, Archer's Garage on Fenian Street, a rare art deco building, was illegally demolished over the June bank holiday weekend and had to be rebuilt more or less in facsimile, which was, whatever one thinks of facsimiles, a sign that the old impunity was ending.

What saving actually meant

The results can be counted. McDonald's figures have the inner city population, including the docklands, rising to more than 130,000 by 2011, and Dame Street, which he remembered as a dark thoroughfare enlivened only by the Olympia, is now lined with restaurants and shops that hardly close. Much of the agenda set in the Synod Hall, from repopulating the centre to recasting the road plans and giving more space to buses, bicycles and people on foot, has become ordinary public policy, so ordinary that younger planners may not realise it was ever heresy.

And yet it would be a strange history of Dublin that ended on a note of triumph. By 2016 McDonald was writing that the city was in crisis again, this time a crisis of homelessness, rents and sprawl rather than dereliction, and wondering aloud whether another Crisis Conference was needed. Aldborough House, the last of the great Georgian mansions, was still rotting on Portland Row when he retired, and the fire regulations that make it so hard to put homes over shops remain, as he put it, a serious impediment.

For a planner, whether acting for a developer or a residents' association, the lesson of the saving years is not that the campaigners were always right or the officials always wrong. It is that cities are saved by people choosing to live in them, by the rules that make that possible, and by the slow, unglamorous work of repairing what is there before reaching for the bulldozer. That argument was made in a church hall forty years ago, and the vacancy and dereliction debates of 2026 suggest it has not quite finished being made.

Further reading

Saving the City: How to Halt the Destruction of Dublin, by Frank McDonald (Tomar, 1989)
The Construction of Dublin, by Frank McDonald (Gandon, 2000)
The evolution of urban conservation in Ireland: evidence from Dublin city, Trinity College Dublin research archive: http://hdl.handle.net/2262/67653
The Frank McDonald collection, Dublin City University Library: https://artsandculture.google.com/story/frank-mcdonald-collection-dublin-city-university-libraries/JQUhSErgYWxr5w?hl=en
The Death and Life of Great American Cities, by Jane Jacobs (Random House, 1961)

Planners Take, 30 October 2026

Every Irish town has one: the house with the buddleia growing out of the gutter, the shopfront whose faded lettering advertises a business that closed before the euro arrived, the upstairs windows that have been dark for so long that nobody on the street can remember them lit. We have had a law to deal with such places since 1990, and a levy on their owners for most of that time, and yet the buildings remain, with a stubbornness that would be admirable if it were not so expensive for everybody else. This week a software engineer, Michael Gannon, did something that the State has been promising to do for years, which is to put the derelict sites registers kept by local authorities together in one place, on a website that lists more than 2,700 properties around the country.

The numbers he draws from that exercise are worth pausing over. By his estimate, these properties could be worth something over €500 million if they were developed for housing, and their owners owe in the region of €49.5 million in unpaid derelict sites levies. In 64 cases, he reckons, the owner owes more than the property is worth. One does not have to accept every valuation to see the shape of the problem. The levy, at 7 per cent of market value a year, was meant to make holding a derelict building more costly than doing something with it. In practice, it has too often been a bill that was issued, or not issued, and then quietly left to accumulate.

The Government's response, being carried through the Finance Act, is to hand collection of the levy to the Revenue Commissioners. From January, local authorities will be legally obliged to keep a derelict sites list and to send it to Revenue, and owners will have until the middle of 2028 to settle what they owe. A national digital register, with maps and standard details for each property, is to be published annually. It is hard to read this as anything other than a polite expression of frustration with councils, and it is a reasonable one, but it is only half the story.

Anyone who has worked in a planning department knows why derelict sites registers are patchy. Entering a property on the register is a legal process, with notices, objections and the possibility of challenge, and it falls to small teams who are also dealing with unauthorised development, vacant site levies and the ordinary daily traffic of complaints. Ownership is frequently tangled in probate, in family disagreement, or in companies that exist mainly on paper. Collection was harder still, because a council chasing a local owner for a levy is a council chasing a ratepayer and a voter. Moving collection to Revenue removes some of that awkwardness, but it does not remove the need for a council to identify, inspect and formally list the property in the first place, and the new regime will only be as complete as the registers that feed it.

There is also a fair point to be made on the other side. Not every owner of a derelict building is a speculator sitting on a windfall. Some are elderly people who inherited a property they cannot afford to repair; some are waiting on a planning permission, a fire certificate or a builder who never arrives. The State has been more generous here than it is sometimes given credit for: the vacant property refurbishment grant offers up to €70,000 to bring a single property back into use, and investors converting space over shops can now receive up to €135,000. A tougher levy makes sense precisely because the carrot is already on the table.

For planners, the lesson is that dereliction is a land management problem before it is a design problem. A public register is a useful thing in itself, because it lets communities, councillors and would-be buyers see what is sitting idle, and visibility has a way of concentrating minds. But the real test will come in 2028, when we see whether the levies are actually paid, whether properties change hands, and whether the dark windows on our main streets begin, one by one, to light up again. If they do not, the next step will have to be a more confident use of compulsory purchase, and a willingness by local authorities to take on buildings themselves rather than simply recording their decline.

Irish Town Planner Planning News Roundup, 30 October 2026

Here is today's round-up of town planning news from around Ireland, covering a High Court order reviving a 300-home Fermoy scheme, a large Land Development Agency land purchase in Dublin 15 and Meath, 124 apartments approved on appeal at Dunboyne, a new national website of derelict properties, 34 homes for Ballyhaise and a fresh DAA application at Dublin Airport.

High Court quashes refusal of 300-home Fermoy scheme

The High Court has quashed, with the consent of both sides, An Coimisiún Pleanála's September 2025 refusal of permission to Cumnor Construction Limited for 242 houses, 94 apartments and duplexes and a crèche on an 11.75-hectare site at Coolcarron, about 1km from Fermoy, Co Cork. The scheme, lodged as a strategic housing development in April 2022, had been refused because it did not provide the playing pitches required by the local area plan. The application has now been reactivated on the Commission's website, with a fresh decision due by late February 2027.

Source, Irish Examiner, 29 October 2026: https://www.irishexaminer.com/business/companies/arid-41930553.html

LDA buys land for about 3,000 homes at Kilmartin and Calliaghwee

The Land Development Agency has acquired 108.5 hectares of greenfield land at Kilmartin, Dublin 15, and Calliaghwee, Co Meath, with about 85.7 hectares in Fingal and 22.8 hectares in Meath, close to bus services and the Dunboyne commuter rail line. Initial studies suggest the lands could accommodate around 3,000 homes along with commercial space and community amenities. The agency notes that any development will be subject to rezoning, masterplanning, infrastructure provision, environmental assessment and statutory planning approval.

Source, Land Development Agency, 29 October 2026: https://lda.ie/news/land-3000-new-homes

124 apartments granted on appeal at Dunboyne North

An Coimisiún Pleanála has granted permission, subject to five revised conditions, to Marina Quarter Ltd, a Glenveagh Homes subsidiary, for 124 apartments in three four- and five-storey blocks at Bennetstown, south of the M3 Parkway rail station in Dunboyne North, Co Meath. The scheme replaces 76 apartments previously permitted there, and Meath County Council's grant in July had been appealed by neighbours who raised overshadowing, privacy and infrastructure concerns while saying they did not oppose new housing. The Commission's decision is dated 22 October.

Source, Irish Independent, 30 October 2026: https://www.independent.ie/county/meath/an-coimisiun-pleanala-grants-green-light-for-124-apartments-in-meath-following-appeal/a/163441734.html

New website lists 2,700 derelict properties

A new website, derelictproperties.ie, built by software engineer Michael Gannon from local authority derelict sites registers, lists more than 2,700 properties, which he estimates could be worth over €500 million if developed for housing and whose owners owe about €49.5 million in levies. From January, councils will be legally required to keep a derelict sites list and send it to the Revenue Commissioners, who will take over collection of the 7 per cent annual levy, with owners given until mid-2028 to pay arrears. The Government also plans to publish an annual national digital register of derelict sites.

Source, The Irish Times, 30 October 2026: https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/housing-planning/2026/10/30/new-derelict-buildings-website-lists-2700-residential-properties-countrywide/

34 homes approved at Ballyhaise, Co Cavan

Cavan County Council has granted permission, subject to 25 conditions, to Woodfort Homes Ltd for a €10 million development of 34 homes on a four-acre site at Townparks, Ballyhaise, accessed from Oakwood Lane off the R212. The scheme comprises 21 two-bedroom homes, 12 three-bedroom homes and one four-bedroom home, with 75 car parking spaces. Separate applications for 61 homes at Latt and 36 at Creighan, on the outskirts of Cavan town, were lodged last week.

Source, Irish Independent, 30 October 2026: https://www.independent.ie/county/cavan/cavans-building-boom-continues-apace-as-dublin-construction-firm-given-green-light-for-multi-million-euro-housing-development/a/163778330.html

DAA seeks changes to Dublin Airport US pre-clearance upgrade

DAA has lodged a new planning application to amend the upgrade of the US Customs and Border Protection pre-clearance facility at Dublin Airport that An Coimisiún Pleanála approved in May 2025, including an additional storey. Its consultants say constraints emerged from stakeholder engagement, updated passenger modelling and revised US requirements, and that the changes are not intended to facilitate passenger growth but to provide more queuing and waiting space, easier way-finding and more commercial areas.

Source, The Irish Times, 29 October 2026: https://www.irishtimes.com/business/2026/10/29/daa-returns-to-planners-with-upgrade-to-agreed-us-pre-clearance-area-revamp/

Thursday, 29 October 2026

Planners Take, 29 October 2026

There is a particular kind of Irish policy that arrives with a fanfare and then waits, like a guest at a wedding who has been seated at the wrong table, for somebody to notice it. The planning exemption for modular homes in back gardens may be turning into one of them. When councillors in Tipperary asked this month how the new rules were being received, a senior planner told them that the council had received eleven notifications in all, and that not one commencement notice had yet followed. In a county of Tipperary's size, eleven is not so much a trickle as a rumour.

It is worth recalling what the exemption actually offers, because the detail matters more than the headline. A homeowner may place a standalone unit of up to 45 square metres in the back garden of their principal residence without seeking permission, provided they notify the council in advance and lodge a commencement notice. The unit can house a family member or a long-term tenant, but it cannot be sold off separately or let to tourists. It is, in other words, a carefully fenced concession, designed to let an ageing parent live close by or to give an adult child a door of their own, without opening the gate to a back-garden property market.

The temptation is to read the Tipperary figure as proof that the idea has failed, and some will. That would be premature. The rules only came in over the summer, households do not commission a second dwelling on a whim, and the costs of a well-built unit, together with connections to water and drainage, are not trivial for a family already carrying a mortgage. Building regulations still apply in full, as the council was careful to point out, and that alone gives pause to people who imagined something closer to a garden shed with a kettle.

There is also a quieter difficulty, which the same meeting brought into the open. The exemption does not reach back in time. Anyone who installed a modular unit before the rules changed is still, in the language of the planning code, unauthorised, and must seek retention permission even if the unit would now satisfy every condition. One councillor feared that people might treat the exemption as a free-for-all, skip the notification and leave themselves open to warning letters or enforcement; there is a related risk that households who acted in good faith before the rules arrived find themselves in the enforcement queue while their neighbours proceed lawfully under a notification form.

None of this is a reason to abandon the measure. For councils, a modest uptake carries modest administrative burden, and a light-touch route for genuine family housing is a reasonable thing for the State to offer. For communities wary of piecemeal backland building, the size limit, the ban on separate sale and the principal-residence test are real protections rather than decoration. And for housing delivery, the honest answer is that garden units were never going to move the national figures much; the same week brought Cabinet approval for a bill allowing Home Building Finance Ireland to lend to smaller builders for zoned land before permission, a reminder that the larger levers lie elsewhere.

What the Tipperary figure does suggest is that an exemption is only as useful as the public's understanding of it. Clear guidance from councils, a straightforward path for those caught on the wrong side of the start date, and some patience before anyone declares victory or defeat would serve applicants and neighbours alike. Eleven households have taken the first step. It would be no bad thing to find out, in a year's time, how many of them got to the end.

Irish Town Planner Planning News Roundup, 29 October 2026

Here is today's round-up of town planning news from around Ireland, covering 91 new homes for central Bray, a refused oral hearing on the large housing appeal beside Cú Chulainn's Castle in Dundalk, a hotel permission for Rosslare Harbour, a slow start for garden modular homes in Tipperary, three townhouses to replace a derelict Nenagh pub and Cabinet approval for State land finance for smaller builders.

91 homes approved off Vevay Road, Bray

Wicklow County Council has granted conditional permission to Lisava Ventures Limited for 91 homes on 1.56 hectares of former Pembroke Estate land between Vevay Road, Church Road and Churchlands Road in Bray, following a further information request. The scheme comprises 42 apartments in a four- and five-storey block, 28 duplexes and 21 three-storey houses, with 120 car parking spaces, almost 3,000 sq m of public open space and works to a protected stone boundary wall on Church Road. The decision, dated 21 October, was made despite concerns raised over the loss of trees on the site.

Source, Irish Independent, 29 October 2026: https://www.independent.ie/county/wicklow/green-light-for-91-home-development-in-the-heart-of-north-wicklow-despite-concerns-over-loss-of-trees/a/163512105.html

No oral hearing for Dundalk housing appeal beside Cú Chulainn's Castle

An Coimisiún Pleanála has refused a request from the Save Cú Chulainn's Castle group for an oral hearing into appeals against Grandspect Limited's large-scale residential development of more than 1,000 homes on about 96 acres at Castletown Road, Dundalk, which Louth County Council granted in July. The appeals, lodged by ten parties including local councillors, An Taisce and the County Louth Archaeological and Historical Society, raise concerns about the setting of the monument, archaeology and landscape. The case will now be decided on the written submissions, with the Commission previously indicating a decision date of 1 December.

Source, Irish Independent, 28 October 2026: https://www.independent.ie/county/louth/oral-hearing-denied-as-appeal-continues-for-objectors-to-housing-plan-near-cu-chulainns-castle/a/163664757.html

Hotel use approved for former Great Southern in Rosslare Harbour

An Coimisiún Pleanála has upheld Wexford County Council's permission for alterations to the former Great Southern Hotel in Rosslare Harbour, including roof repairs and an increase from 102 to 107 rooms, on condition that it is used as a hotel. Ceann Comhairle Verona Murphy had appealed, arguing that the implemented nursing home permission meant a return to hotel use needed a new application, but the inspector found hotel use acceptable in principle under the settlement plan. The inspector raised concerns that kitchen pods on each floor made the layout more akin to a hostel, and recommended a condition tying the permission to hotel use; the owner says full works will begin in 2027.

Source, Irish Independent, 28 October 2026: https://www.independent.ie/county/wexford/planning-authority-grants-permission-for-new-hotel-in-rosslare-harbour-as-developer-confirms-full-development-works-will-commence-in-2027/a/163523637.html

Only 11 garden modular home notifications in Tipperary

Tipperary County Council has received just 11 notifications from homeowners intending to install a modular home of up to 45 sq m in their back garden under the planning exemption introduced over the summer, and no commencement notices have yet been lodged. The units may house family members or long-term tenants but cannot be sold separately or used for short-term letting, and the council must be notified before works begin. A senior planner told councillors that the exemption does not regularise units already installed, which would need retention permission.

Source, Irish Independent, 29 October 2026: https://www.independent.ie/county/tipperary/just-11-tipperary-homeowners-notify-council-of-plans-for-modular-homes-under-new-rules/a/162968346.html

Derelict Nenagh pub to make way for three townhouses

Tipperary County Council has decided to grant permission, subject to 12 conditions, for the demolition of the derelict former Malthouse pub at 7 and 8 McDonagh Street, Nenagh, and its replacement with three two-storey terraced houses. The site originally held three terraced houses, and the design was revised to lower the buildings on Rossa Place and keep a shopfront appearance on McDonagh Street; the applicant said rising construction costs made three homes the only viable option. The decision, issued on 22 October, remains open to appeal.

Source, Tipperary Live, 28 October 2026: https://www.tipperarylive.ie/news/nenagh/tipperary-pub-to-be-demolished-as-permission-is-granted-for-three-new-houses-9315828

Cabinet approves bill on State finance for zoned land

Following reports earlier in the week, the Tánaiste and Minister for Finance, Simon Harris, has secured Cabinet approval to draft the Home Building Finance Ireland (Amendment) Bill 2026. The bill would allow HBFI to lend for the purchase of residentially zoned land before planning permission is secured, a gap the Department of Finance says weighs particularly on smaller builders who lack the equity to buy and advance several sites at once.

Source, gov.ie (Department of Finance), 28 October 2026: https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-finance/press-releases/t%C3%A1naiste-simon-harris-moves-to-unlock-finance-for-small-builders-to-purchase-zoned-land/

Wednesday, 28 October 2026

Data Centres in Ireland: A Debate That Deserves Better

A personal discussion piece by Brendan Buck. It is not the opinion of BPS Planning.

I am a town planner, and if a developer or a community asked me to act for them on a data centre I would do so, and do it properly for either. My interest here is narrower than that. I would like the argument, when it is had, to be had fairly: without jibes, without insults and without misinformation from either side.

A word about Brexit

It is a peculiar feature of Irish public life that a planning dispute can go from the technical to the tribal in about a week. The latest turn came on 24 October, when The Journal reported on an interview with Ronan Kelly, chief executive of the lobby group Digital Infrastructure Ireland. Those who stop data centres, he suggested, resemble the crowds who cheered the Brexit vote. The opposition, he said, is fuelled by disinformation that has blown across from American politics. The AI industry, he told the paper, is like water: it will always find its way, and if Ireland's grid is the obstacle, it will simply flow to the next country.

There is something in this, and it deserves to be said first. Investment does move, and it moves quickly. Mr Kelly also concedes that his own sector has been too secretive and is preparing materials to explain itself to the communities beside which it builds. He says that 107 Irish data centres already use closed-loop cooling, which, if true, bears directly on the water question. It is his figure, and it would be worth having it tested independently.

The difficulty lies in the other claim. The Journal's report offers no evidence that foreign money is stirring up Irish objectors, and it records that some 300 people had objected to the Kilmeaden proposal a year earlier, which is hard to put down to a rumour from Virginia. A Brexit comparison is a handy thing to reach for, since it tells the audience what to think of people before it has heard a word they say. It does not help the industry, and it does nothing for the people who will live next door to its buildings.

What the larger argument is about

The debate here is not happening in a vacuum. It sits inside a much bigger argument about technology, power and who gets to decide, and Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor's work on what they call end times fascism, which I have read in detail, is one contribution to it. Their Guardian essay of September 2026 is adapted from their book of the same name. It is concerned with American politics and the tech billionaires. It does not mention Ireland, it touches on data centres only in passing, including the people who have defended their air and water against the sprawling ones, and it nowhere suggests that someone who supports a data centre is an extremist. Nobody should say so on its behalf.

What I take from it is a question that supporters and objectors can both ask, which is who gets the benefit and who is left with the bill. I want a better world, and in my book that means one in which people have a real say in what is built beside them, and in which the gains and the costs of progress are shared fairly.

The case for

The supporters have a real case, and it should be heard in full. The Government says that firms operating data centres here employ about 21,000 people directly, within an ICT sector of more than 180,000. Local authorities benefit as well. The Journal has estimated that councils collect around €62.5 million a year in commercial rates from data centres, about a fifth of South Dublin's rates income. The Maynooth geographer Patrick Bresnihan warned in the same piece that a deepening dependence on that money is risky, which is a fair thing to say and not an argument against the jobs.

Nor is it all bad news on the ground. In Tallaght, waste heat from an Amazon Web Services data centre now warms public buildings and a university, with affordable apartments to follow, through a not-for-profit utility owned by the council. The council estimates it saves more than 1,500 tonnes of carbon a year. Well designed, a nuisance can be turned into an asset.

The case against

Those who object have specific complaints, and the first is about the grid, where the figures are stark. The CSO says that data centres used 23 per cent of the country's metered electricity in 2025, up from 5 per cent in 2015. The SEAI, in Energy in Ireland 2026, puts the figure at 22.5 per cent and attributes 78 per cent of the net rise in electricity demand since 2015 to them, while recording that the European Commission puts data centres at roughly 3 per cent of demand across the Union. EirGrid says the greater Dublin region is now fully constrained for new connections, that the headroom is largely gone, and that a further six gigawatts of interest would double the peak on the system. One does not need an engineering degree to see why a householder, looking at a small island grid and a large industrial customer, begins to wonder about the bill.

Then there is what it feels like on the ground. Kildare County Council voted in September, by 22 to 11 with seven abstentions, against reviewing land zoned exclusively for data centres at Naas. Cllr Bill Clear, who had backed the zoning in 2021, said he had since learned that data centres were not all they were cracked up to be, having visited a site in Clondalkin where the noise and the smell had shocked him. Residents spoke of noise, air pollution and water.

In Kilmeaden, outside Waterford, more than 500 people objected to a campus covering more than a square kilometre. RTÉ reported three large ICT buildings, 16 gas turbines, and more than 300 people taking part in a slow-drive protest. The council refused permission earlier this month, citing traffic and the pressure on water and electricity. The developers had said that the scheme met regulatory guidelines and involved community consultation, and nothing in the reports suggests otherwise. But compliance is a low bar when you are a village of some 300 people being told, as one resident put it, to prepare for ten years of construction.

And in Killala, in Mayo, the council granted permission for a €1.5 billion scheme which An Coimisiún Pleanála then overturned on appeal, saying that the applicant had not shown consistency with the Climate Action Plan and had produced no evidence of a renewable power purchase agreement. The Irish Times found mixed feelings: relief in some quarters, and in another a Fine Gael councillor frustrated after more than seven years of work. One resident complained that developers put these things up "without explaining anything to the local people". That sentence could stand as a summary of most planning rows in the history of the State.

Elsewhere

None of this is peculiarly Irish. In Virginia, the Prince William Digital Gateway, a plan for 23 million square feet of data centres, ended in July after the courts found that the county had failed to follow its own public notice rules in rezoning the land. Whatever one thinks of the project, it died of a procedural failure, which is the most avoidable way for anything to die. In Tucson, the council rejected Project Blue unanimously in 2025, one member observing that giant corporations prefer to operate in the shadows. And across the 13 American states served by the PJM grid, the independent market monitor says data centres accounted for $6.3 billion of the $16.4 billion in the latest capacity auction charges, costs that find their way onto bills.

There are places that have found a middle road. Amsterdam paused new data centres in 2019 and then restarted growth in designated clusters, with caps on power and space. Singapore lifted its pause in 2022 but promised to be more selective in future.

What we have, and what we lack

Ireland is not starting from nothing, though it can sometimes look that way. The Government's 2022 statement on data centres still stands, and the regulator's December 2025 connection policy requires new data centres to bring matching generation or storage and to meet at least 80 per cent of their annual demand from additional Irish renewables. The same notice says that the regulator would prefer a State-led approach, with spatial planning and development targets. In January the Government published its Large Energy User Action Plan, a "plan-led" approach built around green energy parks beside renewable supply.

Last week, however, a Minister told the Dáil that none of the plan's 17 actions is yet complete. The plan names no sites, and the National Planning Statement that would set the criteria is promised only "before the end of this year". Nor does the plan prevent projects being proposed elsewhere. As far as can be found, there are no national planning guidelines dedicated to data centres, which leaves councils and An Coimisiún Pleanála to decide, case by case, what a plan ought to have settled beforehand. It is an old Irish habit to build the thing first and the policy afterwards.

A fair fight

There are two sides to this argument, and both are honest. The supporters see jobs, investment and the digital infrastructure that a modern economy needs. The objectors see a grid, a water supply and a landscape being committed to a single industry without their say. Neither side is helped by calling the other a conspiracy, a mob or a lobby.

The answer is not a ban, and it is not a free-for-all. It is what we have been slow to supply in so many areas, a system. That means national guidelines on siting, scale, noise, water and emissions, in place before the next application and not after it. It means development plans that say plainly where large energy users may go, tied to grid and renewable capacity, so that zoning land means what it says. It means binding standards on water use and heat reuse, with Tallaght as the benchmark. It means community benefit agreed at the start and not offered as an afterthought, and it means independent, published monitoring of power, water and noise once a facility is running.

With clear rules, developers get certainty, communities get a fair hearing, and the decisions can be argued on the facts. People rarely fight what they trust to have been well planned.

Further reading

Planners Take, 28 October 2026

There is a particular kind of planning rule that exists mainly on paper. Since 2019, anyone letting a home for short stays in a rent pressure zone has generally needed planning permission to do so. Seven years on, the Department of Housing's own figures say that only about 1.3 per cent of short-term lets have ever applied. That is not a regulatory regime; it is an honour system that most of the people it covers have chosen to ignore. The Government's Short-Term Letting and Tourism Bill is meant to change that, but one feature of it risks turning seven years of non-compliance into a qualification.

The broad shape of the proposal is sensible. Planning permission for short-term letting would be restricted in 25 areas with populations of more than 20,000, including Dublin, Cork and Limerick. A national register, run by Fáilte Ireland, would require hosts to sign up from 1 December, which for the first time would give councils a reliable picture of where these lets actually are. Anyone who has tried to run an enforcement case on a short-term let knows that the hardest part is often proving the use exists at all; a register goes a long way towards fixing that.

The difficulty lies in the draft national planning statement that sits alongside the Bill. For short-term lets that have been operating for seven years, regardless of where they are, it proposes a presumption in favour of granting permission, provided the property has been in continuous short-term use and has not been the subject of enforcement action. Hosts in areas with fewer than 20,000 people would also have two years to apply.

Seven years is not an arbitrary number to a planner. It echoes the period after which, under our existing law, a council generally loses the ability to bring enforcement proceedings against unauthorised development. Read in that light, the presumption looks less like a loophole and more like an attempt to be consistent with a principle that already runs through the system: after a certain time, the State accepts that the moment for enforcement has passed. There is also a fairness argument. Councils did not have the information or the resources to pursue these uses, and some operators will have invested in good faith on the strength of that inaction.

But the comparison does not hold up well. The seven-year enforcement limit was designed to give certainty about physical development, not to reward a commercial use that was unlawful from the first night it operated and that has a direct, measurable effect on housing supply. The condition that no enforcement action has been taken is close to meaningless when enforcement has been so thin on the ground. Threshold has put the point plainly: permission has always been a legal requirement, and those who operated outside it should not be rewarded with longer transition periods. Sinn Féin has gone further, arguing that the restrictions would be among the weakest anywhere in Europe or the United States.

The stakes are not trivial. Analysis by the Housing Agency, cited in the planning statement, suggests that almost 17,000 properties are being used entirely for short-term letting in areas of high housing demand, and that somewhere between 5,500 and 9,500 could return to long-term use. In a year when councils, the Department and the industry are arguing over every possible lever to increase supply, that is a significant number of homes that already exist, are already serviced and need no new planning permission to be lived in.

My own view is that the register and the restriction in the larger urban areas should be welcomed and brought in without delay. The presumption for long-standing lets, however, should be dropped or narrowed sharply, perhaps limited to lets in areas where there is no evidence of housing pressure. Seven years of non-compliance should be treated as a problem to be solved, not as a track record.

Irish Town Planner Planning News Roundup, 28 October 2026

Here is today's round-up of town planning news from around Ireland, covering criticism of the Government's short-term letting proposals, 85 homes in Tralee cleared on appeal, more apartments for Waterford's North Quays, a new civic park for Sandyford, a housing refusal in Longford over wastewater capacity and a withdrawn apartment scheme in Waterford city.

Short-term letting proposals criticised as too weak

Threshold and Sinn Féin have criticised the Government's Short-Term Letting and Tourism Bill, which would restrict planning permission for short-term lets in 25 areas with populations over 20,000, including Dublin, Cork and Limerick. Critics object to a draft national planning statement's presumption in favour of permission for lets that have operated continuously for seven years without enforcement action, and to a two-year window for hosts in smaller areas to apply for permission; a national register run by Fáilte Ireland is due to open on 1 December. The Department of Housing says only about 1.3% of short-term lets have applied for planning permission since it became a requirement, and that around 43.6% of those applications were approved.

Source: Irish Examiner (27 October 2026)

85 homes in Tralee granted on appeal

An Coimisiún Pleanála has granted permission on appeal for 85 homes and a crèche on a 3.3-hectare site at Caherslee, Mounthawk and Carrigeendaniel in Tralee, upholding Kerry County Council's grant of June 2026 despite local objections. The scheme is a mix of detached, semi-detached and terraced houses, duplexes and apartments, with access and a pedestrian and cycle path off Caherslee Road (R551) and a new wastewater pumping station.

Source: Irish Independent (28 October 2026)

Waterford's North Quays approved for 80 more apartments

Revised plans for six residential blocks at Waterford's North Quays regeneration scheme have been approved, raising the number of apartments in Blocks C to H from 350 to 430 while keeping the permitted footprints and heights of eight and nine storeys. One-bedroom units rise from 106 to 228, the 37 previously approved three-bedroom apartments are dropped, and ground-floor retail and commercial space is slightly reduced.

Source: Waterford News & Star (26 October 2026)

Councillors approve Sandyford civic park

Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown councillors have approved the council's Part 8 proposal for a 0.96-hectare civic park on Corrig Road at the junction with Carmanhall Road in Sandyford, with 37 votes at the October meeting. Almost 60% of the 275 consultation submissions opposed the plan, mainly over the displacement of businesses and organisations from the site, and councillors were given assurances that efforts would be made to help tenants relocate within the Sandyford Business District.

Source: Irish Independent (27 October 2026)

Longford housing scheme refused over wastewater concerns

Longford County Council has refused permission for 30 houses at Silver Birches, Dunbeggan, Stonepark, which would have been reached through the existing estate's roads and connected to its foul sewer, surface water and water networks. Residents of the estate had opposed the plans over concerns about the capacity of the wastewater system; the decision issued on 20 October after further information was sought.

Source: Irish Independent (October 2026)

Keanes Road apartment plan withdrawn in Waterford

An application by Norris Real Estate Holdings Limited for 40 apartments at Tycor on Keanes Road in Waterford city was withdrawn on 27 October, according to council records. Residents of The Willows had objected to the proposed access through their cul-de-sac, citing traffic, road safety and the character of the estate; no reason for the withdrawal is given.

Source: WLR (27 October 2026)

Tuesday, 27 October 2026

Planners Take, 27 October 2026

Zoning land for housing has never been the same thing as building homes on it. Every planner who has worked on a county development plan knows the gap between the two: the residential zoning that sits on a map for years, serviced or not, while the landowner waits, the builder cannot raise the money and the council's core strategy figures quietly fail to materialise. The Government's latest proposal is aimed squarely at one part of that gap, and it deserves a careful welcome.

Tánaiste and Minister for Finance Simon Harris is due to bring a memo to Cabinet on Wednesday on a Bill to widen the remit of Home Building Finance Ireland, the State-backed lender to smaller builders. At present a builder can only borrow from HBFI once it has a site with planning permission. Under the proposal, HBFI would be able to lend for the purchase of land already zoned for residential use before permission is granted. Larger developers would not be able to use it. If approved, a general scheme will be published and sent for pre-legislative scrutiny, and there are suggestions the Government wants it passed quickly.

The case for the change rests on the structure of the industry. A report for HBFI found that more than nine in ten Irish home-builders deliver fewer than 50 homes a year, and that only 11 consistently deliver more than 300. That is a fragmented sector, and it is the small and medium firms that build the infill schemes, the edge-of-town estates and the village developments that make up much of what we see on weekly lists outside the cities. For those firms the hardest money to find is the earliest money: buying a site and carrying it through design, surveys, pre-application consultation and a planning process that can run for well over a year, all on their own capital. Easing that step should, in principle, bring more zoned land into active use.

From a planning perspective, there is a further benefit. A builder who owns its site outright can put more into the quality of its application. In my experience, many weak applications are weak because the applicant is trying to keep pre-planning costs to a minimum, skimping on ecology, drainage or design work that a council will inevitably ask for later by way of further information. Better-funded applicants tend to produce better-prepared files, and better-prepared files are decided faster.

There are reasonable objections. Lending against land without permission is riskier than lending against land with it, and the State is taking that risk. Zoned land is not always serviceable land, and no amount of finance will overcome a lack of water or wastewater capacity. There is also a danger that cheaper finance simply pushes up the price of zoned sites, transferring the benefit to landowners rather than to buyers. And it does nothing about the capacity of planning authorities themselves, which remain stretched, with the commencement of the remaining parts of the Planning and Development Act 2024 paused because of the work-to-rule.

None of these objections is a reason not to proceed, but they are reasons to design the scheme well. Lending should be tied to land that is genuinely serviceable or has a credible servicing plan, and drawdown should be linked to progress towards a planning application so that the measure activates land rather than funding speculation. HBFI and local authorities should share information so that councils know which zoned sites are moving.

My view is that this is a sensible, modest reform that addresses a real bottleneck. It will not on its own deliver the scale of housing the country needs, and the Government does not claim it will. But it treats small builders as the backbone of delivery that they are, and it recognises that the planning system works best when applicants arrive properly prepared.

Irish Town Planner Planning News Roundup, 27 October 2026

Here is today's round-up of town planning news from around Ireland, covering proposed State loans for small builders to buy zoned land before planning permission, a 73-home mixed-use scheme in Clonlara, new homes permitted in Dundalk, a town-centre housing application in Clonmel, concern over the concentration of solar farms in mid-Waterford and a request for further information on the Oriel offshore wind farm.

Small builders could get State loans to buy zoned land before planning permission

Tánaiste and Minister for Finance Simon Harris is to bring proposals to Cabinet on Wednesday that would allow Home Building Finance Ireland (HBFI) to lend small builders money to buy land already zoned for housing before planning permission is granted; at present HBFI finance is available only once a site has permission. Research for HBFI found that more than 90% of home-builders deliver fewer than 50 homes a year, and only 11 consistently deliver more than 300. If approved, a general scheme of the Bill will be published and sent for pre-legislative scrutiny.

Source: The Irish Times (27 October 2026)

73-home mixed-use scheme proposed in Clonlara, Co Clare

Plans have been lodged with Clare County Council for a mixed-use development of 73 homes in the village of Clonlara, made up of 67 houses and six first-floor apartments, together with three commercial units including a shop and a new paved plaza. The 4.13-hectare application, received on 20 October and accompanied by a Natura Impact Statement, also provides for land to be prepared for a public park and playground for the local authority. Observations can be made until 23 November, with a decision due by 14 December.

Source: Irish Independent (27 October 2026)

46 homes permitted on the Long Avenue, Dundalk

Louth County Council has granted Pangreen Limited permission, subject to 16 conditions, for 46 homes in a three- to four-storey development at the corner of The Long Avenue and Tom Bellew Avenue in Dundalk. The scheme is a mix of apartments and duplexes, with 47 parking spaces, a new cycle lane on Tom Bellew Avenue and pedestrian links. The application included a masterplan for the wider lands to the north, where a discount foodstore has previously been permitted.

Source: Louth Live (26 October 2026)

Permission sought for 45 homes in Clonmel town centre

Ormonde Homes Ltd has lodged an application with Tipperary County Council for 27 houses and 18 apartments on a 2.09-hectare site off Davis Road, behind Lidl in Clonmel, the first phase of a scheme that would eventually bring 99 homes to the area. Nine of the units would be social housing, and an archaeological exclusion zone has been built into the layout following site investigations. A second phase is expected to be lodged in the coming weeks.

Source: Tipperary Live (26 October 2026)

Councillors question scale of solar farm applications in mid-Waterford

Councillors in the Comeragh area of Co Waterford have raised concerns about the number of large solar farm applications on agricultural land around Clonea-Power, Stradbally, Portlaw and Kilmeaden. A senior planner at Waterford City and County Council said that, in the absence of national guidelines, each application has to be assessed on its own merits, and that the council has long called for such guidelines. One councillor intends to table a motion seeking a pause on further data centre permissions in the county pending a national assessment of their impacts.

Source: Waterford News & Star (26 October 2026)

Further information sought on Oriel offshore wind farm

An Coimisiún Pleanála issued a further-information request on 13 October on the planning application for the proposed 375MW Oriel offshore wind farm off Co Louth, covering matters including marine archaeology at the Dunany Point landfall, tourism impacts and bat surveys. The developer has until 14 January 2027 to respond, and consideration of the application is paused in the meantime. Separately, Oriel Windfarm Limited has applied to the Maritime Area Regulatory Authority to extend its route-to-market deadline to the end of 2028.

Source: Afloat (24 October 2026)

Monday, 26 October 2026

Planners Take, 26 October 2026

Ireland's planning system has spent two years in a strange half-state, governed partly by the law it is leaving behind and partly by the one it is moving towards. That limbo has just been extended. The Department of Housing has confirmed that further commencement of the Planning and Development Act 2024 is on hold, with 24 parts of the Act still to be switched on, because of the work-to-rule by council staff. The Department describes the delay as being due to circumstances beyond its control and says it will name a new date as soon as it can.

Some context is useful. The 2024 Act was sold as the biggest reform of planning law in a generation. It brought decades of amendments into a single statute, turned An Bord Pleanála into An Coimisiún Pleanála, introduced mandatory timelines for decisions and reformed the rules on judicial review. It has been brought in piece by piece since then, which was always going to be awkward, but the expectation across the profession was that the remaining parts would follow in an orderly way. The pause comes after Fórsa instructed members working in local authorities to withdraw cooperation from any restructuring and from new or changed work practices, following the breakdown of pay talks over the summer. Strike action planned for last Wednesday was suspended after fresh talks at the Workplace Relations Commission, but the work-to-rule remains.

Why should this matter beyond the circle of planners and lawyers who follow commencement orders? Because a planning system is, above all, a set of procedures that people rely on to be predictable. An applicant preparing a large housing scheme needs to know which timelines, which appeal rules and which forms will apply when the application is lodged, and again when it reaches a decision. A community group considering an objection or a legal challenge needs the same certainty. When parts of a new code are live and others are not, every planning department and every consultant has to keep two rulebooks open, and the risk of procedural error rises. In a system where judicial review is already a familiar feature of major projects, procedural uncertainty is not a small thing.

There is a fair argument on the other side. Commencing new procedures means new forms, new software, new public notices and retrained staff, and that is precisely the sort of change in work practices a work-to-rule is designed to withhold. Bringing provisions into force in council offices that are not cooperating with the changes would risk a messier transition than a short delay. The Department says it is keeping the councils and the commission in an advanced state of readiness, and if the dispute is settled quickly, little lasting harm may be done. Workers are entitled to press their case, and the Government cannot reasonably expect councils to absorb a major legal overhaul while the pay question is unresolved.

Still, the episode exposes a weakness in how we reform planning. The Act was drafted with ambition, but its delivery depends on local authority planning departments that have been stretched for years, and the transition has been designed as a long series of separate commencement decisions rather than one clear switchover. That spreads the work out, but it also leaves the reform exposed to any interruption, whether industrial, technical or political.

My view is that the delay itself is less damaging than the uncertainty around it. The Department should publish a clear, dated sequence for the remaining 24 parts as soon as the dispute allows, and give planning authorities and practitioners a reasonable lead-in before each one takes effect. It should also make sure that transitional arrangements for applications and appeals already in the system are spelt out plainly. Planning reform was meant to make the system faster and more certain. A reform stuck halfway does the opposite, and the sooner it is finished, the better for applicants, communities and councils alike.

Irish Town Planner Planning News Roundup, 26 October 2026

Here is today's round-up of town planning news from around Ireland, covering a pause in commencing the Planning and Development Act, a reported curb on new homes from leading housing providers, a 70-home scheme at a protected former convent in Donnybrook, a large housing application near Blarney, a third-party appeal against 174 homes in Portlaoise and planning enforcement on O'Connell Street.

Work-to-rule pauses commencement of the Planning and Development Act

Further commencement of the Planning and Development Act 2024 has been paused because of the work-to-rule by council staff, with 24 parts of the Act still to be brought into force. The Department of Housing confirmed the pause is due to “circumstances beyond its control”, after Fórsa told members in local authorities to withdraw cooperation from restructuring and new work practices. The Department says it will keep working with planning authorities and An Coimisiún Pleanála to stay ready, and will give a new commencement date as soon as possible.

Source: Irish Examiner (26 October 2026)

Housing providers reportedly told to limit number of new homes

The Irish Independent reports that providers of thousands of new homes have been quietly told by the Government to stop building more houses and apartments. Sinn Féin has described the directive as “ludicrous”, amid fears that middle earners will be hit hardest.

Source: Irish Independent (25 October 2026)

70 homes proposed at former Dominican convent in Donnybrook

Muckross Park Developments has applied to Dublin City Council for up to 70 homes on the former Dominican convent and chapel site at Marlborough Road, Donnybrook, beside Muckross Park College. The plans include a new five-storey block of 29 apartments, partial demolition and refurbishment of Muckross Park House, a protected structure, for 25 apartments, conversion of the former chapel into 10 apartments and six houses in the walled garden. The site was sold by the Dominican Sisters for a total of €8.4 million in 2021.

Source: The Irish Times (26 October 2026)

Kilmoney Homes seeks permission for 319 homes near Blarney

Kilmoney Homes Ltd has applied to Cork City Council for a large-scale residential development of 319 homes on a 10.6-hectare site at Dromasmole, about 2.5km from Tower, made up of 237 houses and 82 duplex and simplex units, with a two-storey childcare facility for up to 110 children. Access would be from a new entrance on the Bawnafinny Road. Submissions are accepted until 19 November, with a decision due by 10 December.

Source: The Echo (25 October 2026)

Appeal lodged against 174 homes at Dargan Woods, Portlaoise

A Forest Park resident has appealed to An Coimisiún Pleanála against Laois County Council's grant of permission for 160 houses, 14 apartments and a 67-place crèche extending the Dargan Woods estate off the Borris Road in Portlaoise. The appeal targets a proposed pedestrian and cycle link next to Forest Park, raising noise, environmental and anti-social behaviour concerns; the council had granted permission with 26 conditions after finding the developer's justification for the links acceptable.

Source: Laois Live (25 October 2026)

Planning enforcement steps up on O'Connell Street

Dublin City Council has taken more than a dozen planning enforcement cases over unauthorised shopfronts and advertising on O'Connell Street, following complaints from the new Dublin City Development Company led by Robert Watt, and a new restaurant on the street has been permitted on condition that it has no takeaway element. In an editorial, The Irish Times welcomed the moves as early signs of revival but said investment around the former Hammerson site, MetroLink and the GPO must be brought together in a coherent plan.

Source: The Irish Times (editorial) (25 October 2026)

Sunday, 25 October 2026

The Thick Father Problem: Following a Parent into a Degree

A personal Sunday discussion piece by Brendan Buck. It is not the opinion of BPS Planning.

A confession at the kitchen table

I did geography as part of my degree in Trinity. My son is now studying geography and statistics in UCD. In most families that would be a touching bit of heritage, a map folded and passed across the table. In ours it comes with a complication. He had a Leaving Cert points total that, as I understand the CAO, opens most of the doors in the building. He could have studied almost anything. He walked past the corridors with the brass plates and chose the one with the maps in it. Then he added statistics, which I am told is where you have to be right rather than merely interesting.

I have therefore concluded that I am the thick father. If the cleverest option available is the subject Dad did, what does that say about Dad? It is a joke, mostly. But it set me wondering about something I had never properly asked. How often do children actually follow a parent into a field of study, and why?

What the research says about following in footsteps

The first thing to say is that the numbers are bigger than I expected. A Swedish working paper by Adam Altmejd, published through the IFAU research institute in 2023, reports that university graduates are more than three times as likely to hold a degree in the field their parent graduated in. Three times is a big family resemblance, and the sort of figure that should make anyone suspicious, because families share a great deal besides a surname: schools, neighbourhoods, bookshelves and expectations.

The clever part of Altmejd's paper is that it tries to separate the resemblance from the cause. He looked at Swedes who applied to university programmes between 1977 and 1992, and compared parents who only just got into a field with parents who only just missed it and ended up studying something else. Since the two groups were otherwise much alike, the difference in what their children later studied is a fair estimate of the parent's own influence. That influence is real. Children became about 50 per cent more likely to graduate in a field if their parent had enrolled in it. In the paper's main estimate that works out at roughly two percentage points. It was far larger in some fields. For technology, engineering, medicine and business, parental enrollment raised a child's chances by between 2.0 and 12.8 percentage points.

Two details struck me. The first is that the effect is not about passing on skills. The paper finds no sign that a parent's field raises the child's grades in that subject, and little evidence of a comparative advantage. What seems to matter is that the parent makes a path visible. Children were more likely to follow a parent of the same gender, and less likely to follow a parent whose field had weak labour market prospects. Altmejd calls this the parent as role model, and cautions that his data cannot fully settle the question. The second detail is a mild comfort. On average 28 years separate a parent's university application from a child's, so children are following less what the parent studied than what the parent did with it.

On the same-gender point, I should record that a father and a son are the pairing the research says is most likely to repeat itself. I claim no credit. I merely note it for the file.

Other studies, other professions

The wider literature points the same way. A study of Swedish adoptees by Matthew Lindquist, Joeri Sol and Mirjam Van Praag found that parental entrepreneurship raises a child's chances of becoming an entrepreneur by about 60 per cent. Because some of the children were adopted, the authors could separate what comes from birth parents from what comes from the people who raised them. Post-birth factors accounted for about twice as much as pre-birth ones, and the evidence pointed, suggestively, to role modelling. In plain English, it is largely about what you see done at home.

Entrepreneurship is not a degree, but the pattern recurs in Hans Hvide and Paul Oyer's Norwegian paper on "dinner table human capital". Using Norwegian register data, they found that a majority of male entrepreneurs start a firm in the same or a closely related industry as their fathers' employment, and that those who do tend to outperform others in the sector. They also found that higher-IQ entrepreneurs were less likely to follow their fathers. I mention that for balance. It concerns firms and not degrees, and my son appears to have ignored it anyway.

For degrees themselves, a Norwegian register study of everyone born between 1955 and 1980 found that children often reproduce their parents' fields, most of all where parents are professionals with master's degrees or higher. Even children who chose differently tended to choose something close. A Swedish thesis by Helen Dryler found a "same-sector" effect on choice of upper-secondary programme, somewhat stronger for fathers and sons. Xiaoyu Xia suggests one practical mechanism: students learn what a major might pay from the wages of parents and older siblings.

There is also the sibling effect. A study across Chile, Croatia, Sweden and the United States in the Quarterly Journal of Economics found that a meaningful portion of younger siblings follow an older sibling to the same college or college-major combination. The effect disappears if the older sibling drops out, which suggests that it is the experience and not the brochure that persuades.

What the research cannot tell me

I should be honest about what I did not find. I could find no study of whether the children of geographers become geographers, so I cannot tell you whether geography passes down more or less than medicine or engineering. Altmejd's strongest results are for technology, engineering, medicine and business, and he does not single out geography. Most of the best evidence is Scandinavian, Altmejd's paper is a working paper rather than a journal article, and I found no Irish study of the question. Some of the resemblance is simply families passing on advantages and tastes, and the causal studies can only strip that out for the groups, country and period they study.

A three-fold resemblance is a statement about averages, and my son is not an average. A fairer reading is that a parent in a field makes that field more thinkable, not inevitable. Nor would I take the finding that children avoid parental fields with weak earnings prospects as a verdict on geography. The papers do not test it, and I choose to treat his choice as a vote of confidence in the subject.

Why he chose well

Which brings me to the part where I stop apologising and start boasting. UCD's School of Geography describes its degree as combining data collection, analysis and interpretation, spatial analysis and fieldwork, with Geographical Information Systems, or GIS, among the skills it says employers value. On its course page the programme lists an Introduction to GIS for the Social Sciences in second year and an Applied GIS module later on. Pair that with statistics and he is training in two things the modern economy keeps asking for: where things are, and how sure we can be about them. I do not know the module list for his combination, but I have drawn enough maps without confidence intervals to see the point.

Then there is where it leads. UCD says its geography graduates have found work as GIS specialists with local government agencies and private industry, as researchers and policy analysts with Teagasc, ESRI, NGOs and government departments, and as planners in local government and consultancies, and that many go on to master's degrees in social sciences, spatial analysis, planning, law or business. Trinity's page lists urban and regional planning, environmental consultancy, research and teaching, financial services and foreign affairs among its graduates' careers. In the UK, the Royal Geographical Society's data on graduate destinations puts environment professionals first among the jobs held by human geography graduates, followed by a category that includes planning officers and consultants.

The demand for spatial skills seems real. A TU Dublin presentation to a European mapping body lists a significant deficit of qualified geospatial professionals in Ireland. Tailte Éireann, the State's mapping and land agency, put out a tender notice in March 2026 for a four-year framework, estimated at €2 million, for GIS specialists and development work on its GeoHive and MapGenie services. And a voluntary 2024 salary and skills survey by a GIS recruitment firm found that 79 per cent of respondents held a master's degree or higher, and that people with programming and automation skills such as Python or R commanded higher pay. It was a first-year, self-selected survey, so I would not lean on its salary claims, but a geographer who can code and count looks like a useful creature.

Which is what statistics is for. The Royal Geographical Society argues that geographers combine qualitative and quantitative methods with spatial data analysis, and cites a UK Geospatial Commission estimate of up to £11 billion a year in potential benefit from location data. It is an advocate for the subject, so I take that as an argument and not gospel.

To keep myself honest: geography is not a magic wand. The same RGS figures show that fifteen months after graduating, 7.8 per cent of human geography graduates and 6.0 per cent of physical geography graduates were unemployed, against 6.2 per cent of all first-degree graduates. That is respectable and ordinary, and the "gateway" depends on the skills, the further study and the people you meet on the way.

The planner's bias

I did geography at Trinity as part of my degree and I now work as a town planning consultant, so you may suspect I find geography a natural gateway into planning. The suspicion is fair. In my defence, the Irish Planning Institute's accredited courses are all planning degrees and masters, at TU Dublin, UCD and UCC, so a geography degree is not itself on the list. It is a door and not a destination, but it opens onto the same landscape: land, people, data, and the awkward business of deciding what goes where.

The verdict

So what should a thick father conclude? That children following a parent into a field is real and more common than chance, that the best evidence points to role modelling and information rather than inherited talent, and that none of it tells us about one particular son. He may have chosen geography because of me, in spite of me, or because a teacher once drew a good contour line on a whiteboard. I will never know, and neither will the economists.

What I do know is that he has chosen a subject that teaches you to see the forces behind a place, and another that teaches you to doubt your own conclusions. They are a good pair. If a father's job is to give a son a head start, I will accept the research's most flattering reading: that I made geography seem thinkable. If a son's job is to quietly outdo his father, he has begun well, and he has the statistics to prove it.

One last thing, in the spirit of public service. If anyone at Trinity or UCD, whether a geography society, a department, or a student event, would like a speaker, I am happy to accept the invitation. I would be glad to talk about geography and planning, and, I admit, to embarrass my son in front of his classmates while I am at it. Consider it a standing offer, with baby photographs available on request.

Further reading