Sunday, 25 October 2026

The Cottage on the Bend: A Travelling Planner in Glencoe

A Sunday travel and discussion piece by Brendan Buck. It is not the opinion of BPS Planning, and it does not draw on any project BPS Planning has worked on or is working on.

The drive past

Last weekend I walked Ben Nevis with my daughter, and on the way through Glencoe I drove past a building that used to be one of the signature images of the Highlands. Andy Wightman, writing in The National, described it as "a small white house tucked into the hillside where the A82 sweeps left to face the full majesty of the Three Sisters". I lived in Edinburgh for years in my twenties, and I will say plainly that they were some of the happiest years of my life. Those years are inscribed in my memory, and the Highlands are part of that inscription. I must have passed that bend dozens of times. I had a clear picture of it: whitewash, a pitched roof, a wall to the road, and a great deal of mountain behind.

What I saw this time did not match the picture. To my eye it was a ruin. The paperwork says, more prosaically, that the cottage was bulldozed this spring and that a replacement house has planning permission, the BBC reported. Both can be true of the same roadside: a ruin in the eye, a building site in the file. Either way, a landmark I had stored in my head was gone.

The cottage was Allt-na-Reigh, and for about thirteen years from 1998 it belonged to Jimmy Savile. I will say as little about him as I can. The BBC describes him as one of Britain's most prolific sex offenders, and that is enough for a planning discussion. The questions are the ones a planner asks of any building. What is its history? What can the system do? Did the council do the right thing?

A house older than its notoriety

The notoriety is the shortest chapter of the building's life. According to Wightman's research, the house dates from around 1890, built as accommodation for a roadman and his family on a few hectares of croft land. A Glencoe Estate stalker lived there later, then Rob Downie until the 1960s. The outbuilding, Downie's barn, became a climbers' howff in the 1930s.

In 1961 the house was sold for £1,000 to the mountaineer Hamish MacInnes, who lived there until 1987. In the outbuilding he developed the first all-metal ice axe and early versions of the folding stretcher still used by mountain rescue teams worldwide. One detail is a gift to a planner: in 1975 the National Trust for Scotland acquired a right of pre-emption over the house, first refusal on any sale. When MacInnes sold in 1987, the Trust declined to use it. Savile bought in 1998.

Reports differ on whether anything happened at the cottage itself: Wightman says there is no evidence of it, while the Press and Journal in March 2026 wrote that it is "thought" so. I cannot settle that, and my argument does not depend on it.

After his death in 2011 the cottage was sold at auction in 2013 for £212,000, more than double its £100,000 guide price, the BBC reported. It was repeatedly vandalised, with graffiti, smashed windows and a bicycle wheel thrown on the roof. In 2021 it was bought by Glencoe Cottage Ltd, a company in the Glenshire Group, which the press links to Harris Aslam and his family.

The planning history

I have read the officer's report. In 2021 the new owners applied (21/05434/FUL) to demolish and rebuild. Mountaineering Scotland objected to the design, saying it made the building appear to be "standing proud in the landscape", though it accepted that rebuilding a cottage there was fine in principle. That application was withdrawn in 2023. In December 2023 the National Trust for Scotland objected to the revised scheme, saying the state of the building had to be addressed but that a "deliberate contemporary styling" would "distract and detract" from the glen.

Highland Council's South Planning Applications Committee considered the next application, 2305261/FUL, on 18 June 2024. It proposed demolishing the cottage, building a four-bedroom house on an overlapping footprint, and converting the outbuilding to ancillary accommodation. The site is in the Ben Nevis and Glen Coe National Scenic Area. NatureScot advised that, since the proposal improved a derelict dwelling, it would not harm the integrity of the designation. Officers found it complied with the replacement-house provision of National Planning Framework 4, Policy 17, and noted the new ridge would be about two metres above the old. Councillors approved it unanimously.

Three things in that report struck me.

First, the representations raised landscape, scale, materials, road safety and the National Scenic Area, and one person would have preferred the site "returned to nature". The community council did not object and asked for demolition as soon as possible, as the building was a risk to health and safety.

Second, the former owner barely appears. The site description refers to vandalism "directed towards a former owner/occupier" and to "negativity arising from the former owner/occupier". The appraisal concludes: "There are no other material considerations". The architects, according to the BBC, called him only a "disgraced previous owner". The planning system had the most notorious name in the building's history in front of it and, correctly, could not use it.

Third, the cottage was not a listed building, which matters. Listing is the one mechanism that lets a planning authority resist demolition on heritage grounds, and without it the council had no statutory protection to fall back on. A reputation, however dark, is not a heritage designation, and neither is its absence.

What happened next

Demolition began in March 2025 but stopped, because a building warrant and other approvals were not in place, the BBC reported. A fire damaged part of the outbuilding that February. Early in 2026 Councillor Andrew Baxter called on the council to serve an Amenity Notice, describing the ruin as a "selfie-hotspot". A council spokeswoman replied that permission already allowed demolition, that an Amenity Notice was a "potential route", and that officers were assessing "the appropriate steps", the Herald reported. The demolition warrant was approved on 24 February 2026. By 26 March the BBC reported that preliminary demolition was complete and a new house was to follow. I do not know whether construction has started.

Baxter said he had been calling for demolition for twelve years and that locals were "delighted that it's finally gone". I understand that.

What can planners actually do?

Planning control. An application is decided on the development plan and other material considerations, and those must relate to the use and development of land. A former owner's reputation is not one. That is not squeamishness. If the system could refuse permission because of who once lived somewhere, it would hold a moral veto that nobody wants used on their own street.

Section 179. Where the condition of land adversely affects the amenity of an area, the planning authority may serve a notice requiring "such steps for abating the adverse effect as may be specified" (section 179). Highland Council itself named this route. In a National Scenic Area, with a derelict building beside a trunk road, I think the case for it was strong once the fire had happened, though I do not know where the delay really lay.

Dangerous buildings. Under sections 29 and 30 of the Building (Scotland) Act 2003, where a building endangers the public a council must act to prevent access and protect people, including by demolition if necessary, and can recover its costs from the owner (sections 29 and 30). Highland Council says it may act where an owner does not, its website says. I found no sign that it did here.

Compulsory purchase. Under section 189 of the 1997 Act a local authority, with the Scottish Ministers' authorisation, can acquire land compulsorily where it is suitable for and required to secure development, redevelopment or improvement, or is needed for a purpose in the interests of the proper planning of the area (section 189). I found no record of anyone proposing a CPO for Allt-na-Reigh. I think that was right: the owners wanted to demolish, they had permission, and a CPO against a willing developer would have been hard to justify. The body best placed to buy it by agreement, the National Trust for Scotland, held its pre-emption right in 1987 and declined.

Compulsory sale. As far as I can establish, Scotland has no compulsory sale order for derelict property. A Scottish Government consultation analysis in August 2026 reports 69 per cent support, with calls for safeguards (analysis report), but its programme, as I read it, is to modernise compulsory purchase first.

Revocation. Section 65 lets an authority revoke or modify a permission, but only before the operations are carried out (section 65). As far as I can see, there is no mechanism for "de-planning" an existing home.

The Irish mirror

I know the Derelict Sites Act 1990 better. It defines a derelict site by its effect on neighbouring amenity, character and appearance, through ruinous, derelict or dangerous structures or neglected land. It lets a local authority serve notice requiring measures, acquire a site compulsorily by vesting order, and, in urban areas, charge a levy now set at up to 7 per cent of market value (Derelict Sites Act 1990). The test is the condition of the land, not its history, and that is the Act's virtue. A council using it on a notorious house would ask whether the site is derelict and detracting, not whether the owner was a bad man.

How others have handled it

In Gloucester the city council bought 25 Cromwell Street and its neighbour in 1996 and had them demolished, the rubble ground up or burned to deter souvenir hunters. It consulted the bereaved and residents on the cleared land, which became a walkway (BBC; Local Government Chronicle). Soham's 5 College Close followed in 2004. Those were crime scenes, and the councils acted with the families in mind.

The Fritzl house in Amstetten went the other way. It was sold in 2016 and converted to flats, the cellar long since filled with concrete, and its new owner said neighbours were relieved the "sarcophagus" was gone (ORF, in German).

Braunau am Inn shows what a state does when a private owner will not act. Austria's parliament passed a law in December 2016 to expropriate Hitler's birthplace after about five years of failed negotiation (Guardian); the compensation dispute ran until 2019 (Deutsche Welle). In July 2026 the house reopened as a police station. An expert commission had warned that a museum could keep drawing extremists, and that demolition would obscure a chapter of local history (Guardian). Austria needed a special law. Glencoe never needed one.

The literature has a name for this. Sharon Macdonald calls "difficult heritage" "a past that is recognised as meaningful in the present but that is also contested and awkward for public reconciliation with a positive, self-affirming contemporary identity" (Macdonald, Difficult Heritage).

My view, for what it is worth

Should an offender's home be removed? I do not think there can be a rule. Glencoe fits none of the neat categories. On most accounts it was not a crime scene. It was an ordinary house with a layered past, and the man who lent it notoriety is dead.

On the council, my verdict is mixed but mostly fair. It was right not to turn a moral judgement into a planning ground and to decide the application on landscape, design and policy. Where I would press it is on speed and enforcement. A derelict building stood beside the A82 for years in one of Scotland's best-known glens, and officers weighed an amenity notice only after a councillor called for one in public. Section 179 exists for slow decay of exactly this kind. I would also question a replacement that is larger and higher than the cottage, as several people who love the glen did at the time.

I am wary of erasure. An authority that demolishes what it dislikes sets a precedent I would not want in the hands of a future council with different dislikes. I am equally wary of the shrine. Wightman argued that the house's long history should be celebrated rather than "contaminated" by a short association. A friend of MacInnes of sixty years told the Press and Journal that he wished the site returned to nature. The owners say they will create a commemoration of him. I could not see a condition securing that in the officers' recommended list, and I would have wanted one. I found no published view from survivors about the cottage, and I will not speak for them.

I had always thought a mental map was fixed, and the map of those Scottish years is one I guard closely, because it holds some of the happiest time I have known. It turns out to be a planning document, subject to revision, and none of us gets consulted on every change. Being reminded that the Scotland in my head is a place I lived in and loved, and that it has moved on without me, is not a comfortable feeling, but it is an honest one.

This is a Sunday travel and discussion piece by Brendan Buck. It is not the opinion of BPS Planning, and it does not draw on any project BPS Planning has worked on or is working on. Facts are drawn from the sources below, and where I could not confirm something I have said so.

Further reading

Links sit behind the words in the text above. These are the main sources in full:

No comments: