Tuesday, 27 October 2026

Planners Take, 27 October 2026

Zoning land for housing has never been the same thing as building homes on it. Every planner who has worked on a county development plan knows the gap between the two: the residential zoning that sits on a map for years, serviced or not, while the landowner waits, the builder cannot raise the money and the council's core strategy figures quietly fail to materialise. The Government's latest proposal is aimed squarely at one part of that gap, and it deserves a careful welcome.

Tánaiste and Minister for Finance Simon Harris is due to bring a memo to Cabinet on Wednesday on a Bill to widen the remit of Home Building Finance Ireland, the State-backed lender to smaller builders. At present a builder can only borrow from HBFI once it has a site with planning permission. Under the proposal, HBFI would be able to lend for the purchase of land already zoned for residential use before permission is granted. Larger developers would not be able to use it. If approved, a general scheme will be published and sent for pre-legislative scrutiny, and there are suggestions the Government wants it passed quickly.

The case for the change rests on the structure of the industry. A report for HBFI found that more than nine in ten Irish home-builders deliver fewer than 50 homes a year, and that only 11 consistently deliver more than 300. That is a fragmented sector, and it is the small and medium firms that build the infill schemes, the edge-of-town estates and the village developments that make up much of what we see on weekly lists outside the cities. For those firms the hardest money to find is the earliest money: buying a site and carrying it through design, surveys, pre-application consultation and a planning process that can run for well over a year, all on their own capital. Easing that step should, in principle, bring more zoned land into active use.

From a planning perspective, there is a further benefit. A builder who owns its site outright can put more into the quality of its application. In my experience, many weak applications are weak because the applicant is trying to keep pre-planning costs to a minimum, skimping on ecology, drainage or design work that a council will inevitably ask for later by way of further information. Better-funded applicants tend to produce better-prepared files, and better-prepared files are decided faster.

There are reasonable objections. Lending against land without permission is riskier than lending against land with it, and the State is taking that risk. Zoned land is not always serviceable land, and no amount of finance will overcome a lack of water or wastewater capacity. There is also a danger that cheaper finance simply pushes up the price of zoned sites, transferring the benefit to landowners rather than to buyers. And it does nothing about the capacity of planning authorities themselves, which remain stretched, with the commencement of the remaining parts of the Planning and Development Act 2024 paused because of the work-to-rule.

None of these objections is a reason not to proceed, but they are reasons to design the scheme well. Lending should be tied to land that is genuinely serviceable or has a credible servicing plan, and drawdown should be linked to progress towards a planning application so that the measure activates land rather than funding speculation. HBFI and local authorities should share information so that councils know which zoned sites are moving.

My view is that this is a sensible, modest reform that addresses a real bottleneck. It will not on its own deliver the scale of housing the country needs, and the Government does not claim it will. But it treats small builders as the backbone of delivery that they are, and it recognises that the planning system works best when applicants arrive properly prepared.

No comments: