Ireland's planning system has spent two years in a strange half-state, governed partly by the law it is leaving behind and partly by the one it is moving towards. That limbo has just been extended. The Department of Housing has confirmed that further commencement of the Planning and Development Act 2024 is on hold, with 24 parts of the Act still to be switched on, because of the work-to-rule by council staff. The Department describes the delay as being due to circumstances beyond its control and says it will name a new date as soon as it can.
Some context is useful. The 2024 Act was sold as the biggest reform of planning law in a generation. It brought decades of amendments into a single statute, turned An Bord Pleanála into An Coimisiún Pleanála, introduced mandatory timelines for decisions and reformed the rules on judicial review. It has been brought in piece by piece since then, which was always going to be awkward, but the expectation across the profession was that the remaining parts would follow in an orderly way. The pause comes after Fórsa instructed members working in local authorities to withdraw cooperation from any restructuring and from new or changed work practices, following the breakdown of pay talks over the summer. Strike action planned for last Wednesday was suspended after fresh talks at the Workplace Relations Commission, but the work-to-rule remains.
Why should this matter beyond the circle of planners and lawyers who follow commencement orders? Because a planning system is, above all, a set of procedures that people rely on to be predictable. An applicant preparing a large housing scheme needs to know which timelines, which appeal rules and which forms will apply when the application is lodged, and again when it reaches a decision. A community group considering an objection or a legal challenge needs the same certainty. When parts of a new code are live and others are not, every planning department and every consultant has to keep two rulebooks open, and the risk of procedural error rises. In a system where judicial review is already a familiar feature of major projects, procedural uncertainty is not a small thing.
There is a fair argument on the other side. Commencing new procedures means new forms, new software, new public notices and retrained staff, and that is precisely the sort of change in work practices a work-to-rule is designed to withhold. Bringing provisions into force in council offices that are not cooperating with the changes would risk a messier transition than a short delay. The Department says it is keeping the councils and the commission in an advanced state of readiness, and if the dispute is settled quickly, little lasting harm may be done. Workers are entitled to press their case, and the Government cannot reasonably expect councils to absorb a major legal overhaul while the pay question is unresolved.
Still, the episode exposes a weakness in how we reform planning. The Act was drafted with ambition, but its delivery depends on local authority planning departments that have been stretched for years, and the transition has been designed as a long series of separate commencement decisions rather than one clear switchover. That spreads the work out, but it also leaves the reform exposed to any interruption, whether industrial, technical or political.
My view is that the delay itself is less damaging than the uncertainty around it. The Department should publish a clear, dated sequence for the remaining 24 parts as soon as the dispute allows, and give planning authorities and practitioners a reasonable lead-in before each one takes effect. It should also make sure that transitional arrangements for applications and appeals already in the system are spelt out plainly. Planning reform was meant to make the system faster and more certain. A reform stuck halfway does the opposite, and the sooner it is finished, the better for applicants, communities and councils alike.
No comments:
Post a Comment