Sunday, 15 November 2026

Planner’s Take, 15 November 2026

After two years of overlapping rules, 26 November must bring the new Planning Act into one clear system

This is an editorial from BPS Planning, issued for discussion only.

There is a particular weariness that settles over a planning office during a long legal transition. Every pre-application meeting begins with the same question: which Act, which regulations, which guidance? Every design team checks whether last month's document still carries weight. This weekend, architects have said publicly what many practitioners have been saying privately for some time: the staggered introduction of the Planning and Development Act 2024 has made the system harder to use, and that difficulty is slowing the delivery of homes. One comparison is that it is like changing the rules of a game halfway through.

The complaint deserves to be taken seriously, but it also needs to be put in context, because the end of the transition is now in sight. The Department of Housing has confirmed that the remaining parts of the 2024 Act will come into operation on Thursday 26 November, together with the revised planning regulations. Those parts are not minor. They include the new concept of development, the development consent provisions that replace the familiar permission process, environmental assessment, the successor to Part V, architectural heritage, enforcement, appeals, compulsory acquisition and the new urban development zones. Applications lodged before midnight on 25 November will continue under the 2000 Act. Those received from 26 November will be dealt with under the new one.

It is worth recalling how we got here. The 2024 Act was a deliberate rewrite of planning legislation that had been amended so often that few people could say with confidence what it contained. An Coimisiún Pleanála replaced An Bord Pleanála in June 2025. Since then, some new instruments have arrived ahead of the main procedural change. National Planning Statements made under the new Act have begun to replace the old ministerial guidelines, most recently on apartment standards earlier this month. Meanwhile, the day-to-day business of applications, conditions and appeals has carried on under the old legislation. For two years, practitioners have in effect been working in two systems at once.

That is the source of the frustration. A developer preparing a large scheme over eighteen months may begin under one set of assumptions and lodge under another. A council planner may be assessing an application against guidance that is being replaced while the file is open. Agents now face a hard edge: some councils have warned that forms and public notices that refer to the 2000 Act will be declared invalid if they are received on or after 26 November. An invalid application costs weeks, and fees, and in a tight market it can cost a site.

There is a fair counter-argument. Commencing a reform of this scale in one go, without the regulations, forms and staff training in place, would almost certainly have been worse. A phased approach allowed the new Commission to be set up, gave councils time to prepare and avoided a single day on which the whole system might have stalled. Many of the delays blamed on the new law have other causes too: viability, the cost of construction, water and wastewater capacity, and the steady drain of experienced staff from local authority planning departments. It would be wrong to load every slow decision onto the legislation.

Yet both things can be true. Phasing was sensible, and it has also imposed a real cost in uncertainty. The question now is whether 26 November marks a clean break or the start of a further period of confusion. That depends less on the text of the Act than on how it is put into practice. Councils need to apply validation rules sensibly and consistently, so that a minor slip in a site notice does not become a reason to send back a well-prepared application. The Commission needs to publish clear guidance on how it will handle the cases that straddle the two Acts. The Department should be candid about the matters still awaiting guidance and should set out when they will come.

Practitioners have a part to play as well. Applications rushed in before the deadline may simply move the uncertainty into the appeals process. The better course is to learn the new procedures properly and test them through ordinary use rather than reflexive challenge.

The new legislation was sold as a means of bringing clarity, consistency and speed to a planning system that had lost all three. The staggered rollout has tested that promise. From 26 November, there will be no more excuse for running two systems side by side. The architects' warning should be read not as a reason to doubt the reform, but as a reminder that a law only delivers homes once the people using it can rely on it.

No comments: