Two wind farm refusals in north Galway point to the need for plan-led siting
This is an editorial from BPS Planning, issued for discussion only.
An Coimisiún Pleanála has refused permission for the nine-turbine Cooloo wind farm, proposed by Neoen Renewables Ireland on about 739 acres around Barnaderg and Moylough in north Galway. The Commission gave four reasons, relating to environmental, ecological, hydrological and peatland concerns. It is the second large wind project in that part of the county to be refused in a matter of weeks, after the 11-turbine Shancloon scheme was turned down in September. Two more strategic infrastructure applications nearby, at Laurclavagh and Clonberne, were lodged in 2024 and are still awaiting decisions.
It would be easy to read this as a planning system standing in the way of the energy transition. That reading is too quick. A refusal on peatland and hydrological grounds is not an obstacle invented by planners; it reflects some of the hardest lessons Irish wind development has had to learn. The peat slide at Derrybrien in south Galway in 2003, during construction of a wind farm, led to years of litigation and to the Court of Justice of the European Union imposing a lump sum and daily penalties on Ireland for failing to carry out a proper environmental impact assessment. Peat is not just ground to be built on. It stores carbon, holds water, supports habitats and, when disturbed badly, can move. A wind farm that damages a bog can undo part of the climate benefit it was meant to deliver.
That is why the Commission's reasons matter. Under EU law, a project of this kind requires environmental impact assessment. Where likely significant effects on a European site cannot be excluded, appropriate assessment under the Habitats Directive is also required. The ordinary consent test requires adverse effects on the integrity of that site to be ruled out; any derogation is subject to separate, strict legal conditions. The Commission must also, under the Climate Action and Low Carbon Development Act 2015 as amended, perform its functions, in so far as practicable, consistently with the climate action plan and national climate objectives. Climate objectives do not displace the requirements of environmental assessment and habitat protection. Nothing in climate legislation requires a grant on a poorly chosen site.
The more uncomfortable question is why so much effort is being spent on applications that fail. Developers prepare environmental reports, peat stability assessments and hydrological studies, communities mobilise, and the Commission spends many months on each file, only for two schemes in one district to be refused on site-specific environmental grounds. That is costly for everyone, and it does nothing for national targets for onshore wind. The underlying problem is that Ireland still sites most wind farms developer by developer, under wind energy guidelines dating from 2006, with county development plans offering broad designations of areas open to consideration rather than a clear national picture of where turbines should and should not go.
There is a fair counter-argument. Developers know their sites, and a plan-led approach risks long delays while maps are drawn and challenged. Some will also say the Commission has become too cautious, and that a run of refusals sends a poor signal to investors at the very moment the State needs more renewable generation. Those concerns deserve a hearing. But the alternative to careful planning is not faster delivery; it is more refusals, more judicial reviews and more communities who feel that each application is a contest rather than part of a coherent strategy.
The revised EU Renewable Energy Directive points the way. It requires member states to designate renewables acceleration areas, places where environmental sensitivity has been assessed at plan level and where projects can then move faster. Done properly, that approach would steer wind energy away from deep peat, sensitive catchments and protected habitats, and towards land where the environmental case has already been made. It would also give communities an earlier and more meaningful say, at the plan stage rather than application by application.
For practitioners, the lesson from north Galway is practical. Peat depth, slope stability, drainage and downstream water quality need to be understood before site selection, not justified afterwards in an environmental report. For councils, wind energy strategies in development plans should be specific enough to be useful. For Government, the long-promised update of the wind energy guidelines, together with acceleration areas, should be treated as part of the climate programme, not an afterthought.
Ireland needs a great deal more onshore wind. It will get there faster by choosing better places for it, and the Cooloo decision is a reminder that the place matters as much as the turbine.
No comments:
Post a Comment