Thursday, 5 November 2026

Planner’s Take, 5 November 2026

Apartment standards now a National Planning Statement as EU court questions hang over

This is an editorial from BPS Planning, issued for discussion only.

What was anticipated yesterday is now in force. On 4 November, Housing Minister James Browne and Minister of State John Cummins jointly issued the Planning Design Standards for Apartments as a National Planning Statement under section 25 of the Planning and Development Act 2024. It replaces the July 2025 Design Standards for Apartments ministerial guidelines and applies to any planning application, appeal or direct application to An Coimisiún Pleanála determined after that date. For applicants, council planners and Commission inspectors with live apartment files, the operative national design parameters have changed overnight.

The political purpose is clear enough. The ministers said the statement was issued to provide certainty and to boost apartment delivery. The legal vehicle matters. Section 28 guidelines under the 2000 Act could contain specific planning policy requirements that decision-makers had to apply. Under the 2024 Act, development plans and regional strategies must be materially consistent with the national planning policies and measures in a statement and take due account of its guidance. Where the principle of apartment development is already established under the statutory plan and the Compact Settlement Guidelines, determinations after 4 November must apply the statement's design parameters on mix, internal space, dual aspect, floor-to-ceiling heights, stair and lift cores, storage, balconies and amenity. That is the day-to-day test for schemes already in the system and for further information responses still outstanding.

The context that makes the move so charged is the litigation still hanging over the 2025 guidelines. Councillors Darragh Moriarty, David Healy, Dan Boyle and Pádraig McEvoy, together with the late Frank McDonald, challenged those guidelines on the basis that they should have been subject to strategic environmental assessment before adoption. Questions on the Strategic Environmental Assessment Directive have been referred from the High Court to the Court of Justice of the European Union. The ministers have been careful to say that the new statement is issued strictly without prejudice to those proceedings. That formulation should be taken at face value. Issuing a National Planning Statement does not extinguish the judicial review, does not answer the referred questions, and does not, of itself, settle the status of permissions already granted under the 2025 guidelines.

There are reasonable objections, and they deserve a fair hearing. Sinn Féin's Eoin Ó Broin argues that the standards will produce smaller and darker apartments, and that reissuing them as a statement is an attempt to make inferior design standards less susceptible to successful challenge. Social Democrats' Rory Hearne has likewise criticised the reduction in apartment size and standards. Floor area, daylight and outdoor space are not easily retrofitted once built, and Ireland's past experience with poor apartment stock is a reason for caution. Treating design standards as the main lever on viability also risks overlooking construction costs, finance, land values and the shortage of buyers at the prices schemes need. Those concerns go to the content of the standards, not only their legal form.

A second objection is legal process. Moving from guidelines to a statement after environmental assessment and consultation puts the instrument on firmer ground than guidelines adopted without that assessment. That is a legitimate reason for wanting certainty, and practitioners will welcome a clearer national baseline for decisions from 4 November. It does not follow that the Court of Justice's eventual answers cease to matter. How Ireland classifies national planning documents under the SEA Directive will continue to shape future statements.

For practice, the immediate task is narrower. Check which applications will be determined after 4 November. Read the final text carefully to see which elements are framed as binding national planning policy and which as guidance. Align drawings, schedules and planning reports with the new parameters where the apartment principle is already accepted. Flag transition issues for files lodged under the old guidelines but still awaiting decision. Councils and the Commission will be expected to apply the statement; applicants who ignore it risk refusal or costly redesign late in the process.

On balance, putting apartment standards on a statutory National Planning Statement footing, with the ministers' express without-prejudice reservation as to the pending European proceedings, is a coherent attempt to give decision-makers something firm to apply. Certainty has real value for housing delivery. Standards should still be judged on whether they produce homes people will want to live in for decades, not only on whether they make schemes viable this year. The statement is now the operative national document for post-4 November determinations. The Court of Justice's answers, when they come, will still matter for how Ireland makes national planning policy. Neither point cancels the other.

No comments: