This is an editorial from BPS Planning, issued for discussion only.
Yesterday, at Clonshaugh in north Dublin, the sod was turned on a sewage treatment plant, with the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance among those marking the occasion. Sewage works rarely draw senior ministers. That this one did says a good deal about where the housing debate now stands. The Greater Dublin Drainage Project, Uisce Éireann says, will provide wastewater capacity for up to 185,000 new homes across north Dublin and parts of Meath and Kildare. Without it, much of the land zoned for housing in the region would remain lines on a map.
The history of the scheme is a lesson in itself. Planning for it began some two decades ago. Uisce Éireann applied to An Bord Pleanála in June 2018, and permission granted the following year was followed by a long series of legal challenges. The planning board gave it the green light in July 2025, and a final challenge was settled last December. Preliminary works are now under way, but main construction is not due to start until the end of next year or early 2028, and the plant is expected to be operational in 2031. Over that time the estimated cost has roughly quadrupled, to between €1.9 billion and €2.3 billion. As the Minister for Finance put it at the ceremony, the cost of delay is very significant across all capital projects.
The wider numbers point the same way. This year's completions are expected to reach about 40,000, a real improvement. But, as an Irish Times analysis noted this morning, only 32,000 to 36,000 planning permissions are being granted each year, while something closer to 70,000 would be needed to sustain 50,000 or more completions, because not every permission is built. Insiders quoted in that analysis point to capacity in the water network and the electricity grid as the main constraint. Separately, the Construction Industry Federation has said that homes due to finish this year have been held up by delays in water and electricity connections, and it wants more time under the development levy waiver scheme as a result.
For planners, this exposes an uncomfortable gap between what the system promises and what it can deliver. National policy expects councils to zone land that is serviced or can be serviced within the life of a plan, and councils have rezoned considerable areas at the Government's request. Yet a zoning objective does not lay a pipe or connect a substation. Much of that land, as the same analysis observes, is not yet ready to build on. Applicants are asked to demonstrate that a connection is feasible; communities are told that new homes will come with services. When the trunk infrastructure is years behind, both promises ring hollow, and refusals or long delays on infrastructure grounds become the norm on otherwise suitable sites.
There are fair counter-arguments. Large wastewater schemes carry real environmental risks, and the people who challenged this one were entitled to ask the courts to test the decisions. The law requires proper environmental assessment, including under the EU Habitats and Environmental Impact Assessment Directives, and that assessment is not a formality to be skipped in a hurry. The Chief Justice remarked earlier this month that it is too easy to blame the courts, and that much delay in planning occurs earlier in the process. The Government has also begun to respond, with the €1 billion Housing Infrastructure Investment Fund aimed at unlocking land at 82 locations around the country.
None of that changes the central point. A drainage scheme that takes 20 years from conception to operation is not compatible with a housing target set for 2030. The problem is not one decision or one court case but a system in which infrastructure is planned project by project, often after the housing need has become acute, and in which each stage, from design and consent to funding and procurement, runs in sequence when parts of it could run in parallel.
The better approach is to treat water, power and transport capacity as the starting point of housing policy, not the last hurdle. That means utilities and councils agreeing long-term growth areas together, so that infrastructure is designed, assessed and funded years ahead of the homes it will serve. It means robust environmental assessment done once, early and well, so that it stands up in court. And it means publishing clear programmes showing when each strategic site will be serviced, so that applicants and communities know what to expect.
The start at Clonshaugh is welcome. The real test is whether the next scheme of this scale, wherever it is needed, can be delivered in half the time. If it cannot, the housing targets will keep slipping, however many permissions are granted.
© Brendan Buck 2026. Cite as: Buck, B. (2026) 'Dublin's drainage scheme took two decades, and the next generation of housing infrastructure cannot wait that long', Buck Planning, 17 November 2026, https://buckplanning.blogspot.com.
No comments:
Post a Comment