Wednesday, 18 November 2026

Oliver Bond shows that regeneration should be judged by the quality of homes as well as the count

This is an editorial from BPS Planning, issued for discussion only.

For residents of the Oliver Bond flats in Dublin's south-west inner city, the news this morning is mostly a relief. Dublin City Council has revealed a compromise plan for the first phase of regeneration, worked out over months of negotiation with the Department of Housing, and the first planning application is to be lodged this month. People who have lived for decades with damp, mould, sewage problems and rat infestations will be glad simply to see the work start again. But the episode that led to this point deserves more attention than a sigh of relief, because it goes to the heart of how the State measures success in housing.

The background is straightforward. The complex has almost 400 flats, built in the 1930s and 1940s, and many of them do not meet modern size standards. For several years the council planned a deep retrofit and amalgamation programme, combining small flats into fewer, larger homes. In 2023 the Department approved the design of a first phase that would turn 74 old flats in three blocks into 46 new homes. Last April the Department halted that phase, telling the council it could no longer support such a large reduction of homes during a housing crisis.

The revised first phase retrofits and amalgamates the same three blocks to create 54 homes, including 12 studios, together with a community centre. It adds a new block of 49 apartments on a council-owned site at Bridgefoot Street. A second phase would demolish three further blocks of 78 flats and replace them with 109 new apartments, with construction expected between 2031 and 2033. The future of the remaining ten blocks has yet to be decided. A local councillor's description of the outcome as very minimal change from the original proposal is telling. Months were lost to arrive at something close to where the council began.

The Department's instinct is understandable. When the Government's ambition is to build 50,000 homes a year, a public project that ends with fewer homes than it started with looks hard to defend. Every unit counts, and a regeneration that shrinks the stock can seem to move in the wrong direction. There is also a fair point about value: deep retrofit of old blocks is expensive, and public money spent on fewer homes invites questions.

Yet the count of units is a blunt tool when applied to existing homes that are too small for modern life. A flat that fails today's space standards, and that its tenants have endured with mould and vermin, is not the same asset as a well-sized, well-insulated home. Amalgamation does carry a real cost, since the households who no longer fit must be housed somewhere else, and that cost should be counted honestly. But it also produces homes that can serve households for decades to come, and it can relieve the overcrowding that small flats impose on families. Measuring that outcome solely by the net change in units misses most of what regeneration is for, and risks repeating the mistake of the original blocks, which were built to the standards of their day and have aged badly as a result.

The better answer, which the revised scheme points towards, is to assess regeneration at the scale of the whole estate and its surroundings, rather than block by block. The Bridgefoot Street site, the replacement blocks in phase two and the eventual treatment of the remaining ten blocks together offer room for both larger homes and a net gain in supply. Planning such a programme as one coherent strategy, with a clear timeline, would allow the Department to see the overall numbers and the council to protect the quality of individual homes. It would also spare residents the uncertainty of a project paused midway.

There is a lesson here for other councils with ageing flat complexes from the same era. Regeneration involves trade-offs between density, size, heritage, cost and the wishes of existing communities. Those trade-offs are best agreed early, in a published framework that sets out how a scheme will be judged, rather than renegotiated after design work has been approved and residents' hopes have been raised. The new national apartment standards, which allow smaller units in new build, make that clarity more pressing, not less, because the case for amalgamating old flats rests on the very space standards that are now changing.

Oliver Bond is moving again, and that is welcome. The test now is whether momentum holds beyond phase one. A regeneration programme should be judged by the homes it produces and the lives lived in them, not by a single figure on a spreadsheet.

© Brendan Buck 2026. Cite as: Buck, B. (2026) 'Oliver Bond shows that regeneration should be judged by the quality of homes as well as the count', Buck Planning, 18 November 2026, https://blog.bpsplanning.ie/2026/11/oliver-bond-shows-that-regeneration.html.

No comments: